Posts

Showing posts from 2024

REFORMING THE LAW ON DEFILEMENT: A REPLY TO MR. BRADEPT JOSEPH

Image
Author:  Chweya Nyamari ABSTRACT Section 8 of the Kenyan Sexual offences Act No. 5 of 2006 (hereinafter referred to as the Act) was meant to protect children against sexual predators. It is however evident that it did not address instances where children engage in sexual relations amongst themselves. Mr. Bradept through his Article posted on JKUAT Law Review rendered his notion on this controversial topic. This article entails a reply to Mr. Bradept’s school of thought and endeavors to disapprove consensual sexual relationships between adolescents. The article culminates in proposing an amendment to the sentences associated with instances where minors defile themselves. INTRODUCTION First, I must appreciate the exquisite contribution that Mr. Bradept has made on this controversial topic. His argument opened the way for a truly profitable exchange of views between those whose differences center on whether the relevant statutes should be amended to accommodate instances whe

LAW ON DEFILEMENT: A TIME FOR REFORM

Image
Authored by Francis B. Joseph ABSTRACT Like some other African countries, Kenya has the legal age of consent at 18 years. The legal age of consent is a crucial facet of legal and social frameworks concerning sexual relationships. This has had the effect of restricting adolescent consensual sexual conduct. Legislation does not explicitly criminalize consensual adolescent sexual conduct. However, punitive approaches have been put in place to curb such conduct. Adolescents have therefore been subjected to violation of their rights. The laws put in place are not necessarily benevolent to the adolescents who it is designed to protect from harm. This article provides a comprehensive analysis of the legal age of consent in Kenya, examining the statutory frameworks on it and its effect on sexual relations among adolescents. Through a comparative lens, the article briefly looks into the legal age of consent in other African jurisdictions. By synthesizing these different aspects, thi

APPLICABILITY OF THE HARAMBEE PHILOSOPHY IN THE ACTUALIZATION OF ARTICLE 37 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF KENYA 2010

Image
Authored by: Grace Gakii Mutwiri ABSTRACT  Our motto ‘harambee’ was conceived in the realization of the challenges of nation building, the Government and People of Kenya had to pull together in order to meet this challenge. It was more than a motto for it symbolized Kenyan Unity and patriotism. From the Late Mzee Jomo Kenyatta to the Late Former President Daniel Arap Moi, they frequently evoked Harambee during their regimes which enabled them to push many ambitious government-wide initiatives which we still benefit up to date. In the current era, Harambee can be demonstrated in fundraising events to cater for medical bills, to pay for a child’s school fees so as to have access to education. In the recent past weeks, I have seen the dynamic change in what we regard as Harambee. The ‘Gen Z’ have set a revolution that has actualized Harambee in promoting Article 37 of the Constitution of Kenya 2010. From creating civic education both in online platforms as well as physical pla

INHERITANCE BY ILLEGITIMATE AND NON-MUSLIM CHILDREN UNDER SHARIA LAW: THE FLAWED KENYAN JURISPRUDENCE

Image
Authored by: Francis B. Joseph ABSTRACT For a long time, application of Islamic law, especially on matters inheritance, has been viewed as discriminatory and unconstitutional. In its judgement dated 10th November 2023 in Faraj v Mwawasi, the Court of Appeal stated that Islamic law restricting children born out of wedlock from inheriting is discriminatory and such practice should be abhorred. This decision has been the subject of much scholarly debate, with some scholars expecting to hear the Supreme Court’s pronouncement on the matter in case an appeal has been filed. This article argues that the Court of Appeal’s view concerning Islamic law of inheritance is misguided. This is from an analysis of the available Court of Appeal decisions in relation to the matter.  INTRODUCTION Sharia is an Arabic word that means the correct path. In the Muslim religion, it refers to the divine counsel that Muslims follow to live moral lives and grow close to God. Islamic law is an all-embr

PUBLIC PARTICIPATION IN FORMULATION OF TAX POLICIES

Image
  Camara Castro Ouma This paper delves in discussing the principle of public participation during implementation of various tax policies. It provides some of the laws that are likely to be amended through various proposals that have been presented in the Finance Bill 2024. It also explores the sovereign power that belongs to the citizens either directly or through their democratically elected representatives. It focuses on providing analysis of the effects of public participation. From the proposals in the Bill, the paper provides the likely impact that the Finance Bill 2024 is likely to incur to the citizens. INTRODUCTION “Democracy is not a spectator sport. It is a participatory event. If we do not participate in it, it ceases to be a democracy.” – Michael Moore. The Finance Bill 2024 proposes to amend the Public Finance Management Act, Income Tax Act, Value-Added Tax Act, Tax Procedures Act, Excise Duty Act, Miscellaneous Fees and Levies Act, Kenya Revenue Authority Act (Cap

A SECOND THOUGHT TO GIFTS

Image
Hannah Wanjiku In our recent times, the idea of what constitutes a good relationship varies among different people. These ideas are generally referred to as implicit theories of relationships whereby people hold either destiny beliefs or growth beliefs. The theories affect how the relationship is between people. A common way in which people today deem as a means of expressing love is through giving gifts. This is commonly known as a love language. The rate at which people give gifts to their spouses has significantly increased over the past few years. According to a study carried out, Kenyas growing middle classes are giving away 22% of their monthly income, often through informal gifts and support to family, friends and neighbours. This has largely contributed to the growth of many sectors in the economy such as marketing of gifts. There has been increase of gift shops with many gift ideas such as flowers, jewelry, clothes and even cars. Recent research in marketing has shown that

THE RIGHT OF THE STATE TO APPEAL AN ACQUITTAL IN KENYA

Image
Samuel Kahura Article 25 of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010 addresses the rights which are not subject to limitation. Notably, the right to a fair trial is among those rights. Article 50 then deals with the tenets of a fair trial. One of the most important of these safeguards is the right of an accused person if convicted, to appeal to, or apply for review by, a higher court as prescribed by law. This paper is however aimed at looking at the opposite side of the coin which is the right of the State to appeal an acquittal. I shall examine two different scenarios: a) An accused person is completely acquitted. b) An accused person is convicted of a lesser offence by the court in exercise of its power under Section 179 of the Criminal Procedure Code. Legal Framework for the State’s Appeal Currently, the right of the state to appeal an acquittal is provided for under Section 19 of the Security Laws (Amendments) Act No 19 of 2014. The Section amended the Criminal Procedure Cod

Digital Identity in Kenya: Balancing Progress with Constitutional Rights

Image
Allan Mwangi Kiarie Kenya's proposed digital identification (ID) initiative, Maisha Namba, has sparked a nationwide debate surrounding its impact on data privacy, security, and individual rights. This paper explores the legal and ethical complexities surrounding Kenya's digital ID program, examining its goals, obstacles, and constitutional basis. Drawing comparisons with Rwanda's Single Digital Identification (SDID) program, a seemingly successful digital ID system, the paper identifies key challenges hindering Kenya's implementation and proposes recommendations for a responsible and constitutional approach. Introduction Identification systems have served as cornerstones of individual identification for centuries. Kenya, relying on physical ID cards prone to forgery and fraud, aims to introduce a digital ID system, Maisha Namba, utilizing biometric data for enhanced security and service delivery. Digital ID is a unique representation of an individual, organi

THE DOCTRINE OF LAST SEEN

Image
Joshua Kenga Arome  Photo credits;  People Daily February the 9th, 2024 saw Her Ladyship Lady Justice Grace Nzioka of the High Court give a long waited for judgment in the case of Republic v Joseph Kuria Irungu alias Jowie and Jacqueline Wanjiru Maribe , (High Court Criminal Case No. 51 of 2018) whereby the first accused was convicted of the offence of murder contrary to Section 203 as read with    Section 204  of the Penal Code. The second accused was acquitted of the charge in the absence of evidence connecting her to the alleged crime, however, not without the Judge directing the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions to prefer another charge against her. What has sparked debate in various groups, laymen and legal intellectuals, is the doctrine of last person seen that served as what I would term the ratio decidendi of the judgment to find the first accused guilty of murdering one Monica Kimani. It seems the lawyers frowned upon the Judge’s statement that “...